friends cant join my server

[randomdude]

hello all,

i came across a problem when i host a server from my computer people can join with my laptop in lan but over wan they cant join i can see my server in the renegade x server list but it doesnt  have any ping, =-| i have opened port 7777 in my router and modem when i do a port chek it said its open  but still my friends  cant join they see a loading menu of the map and  after that they go to the main menu, when im booting up the server i see this came by ''Could not open TCP Port 7777 - Rcon Disabled''

seems like this issue is gone but still my friend cant join and in the serverlist i dont see any ping

are there other ports that needs to be opened or am i doing something wrong?

 

here is by the way the log when i startup my server:

[0006.26] Init: Character set: Unicode
[0006.26] Log: Executing Class Engine.ServerCommandlet
[0026.30] Log: Initializing Game Engine...
[0026.37] Init: UEngine initialized
[0026.37] Log: Steam Client API is unavailable (not required for servers)
[0026.38] Warning: Warning, Failed to load 'Class None.': Failed to find object 'Class None.'
[0026.38] Warning: Warning, Failed to find object 'Class None.'
[0026.38] Warning: Warning, Failed to load 'Class None.': Failed to find object 'Class None.'
[0026.38] Warning: Warning, Failed to find object 'Class None.'
[0026.39] Log: LoadMap: CNC-Lakeside?Name=Snuffles?Team=255?AdminPassword=-----?GDIBotCount=20?NODBotCount=20?GDIDifficulty=2?NODDifficulty=4?maxplayers=39
[0035.64] Log: Missing cached shader map for material M_RiverWater_OLD, quality 0, compiling.
[0035.64] Warning: Warning, Failed to compile Material RX_Nature.Materials.M_RiverWater_OLD for platform PC-D3D-SM3, Default Material will be used in game.
[0035.68] Log: Missing cached shader map for material M_Grass_Tweak_02a, quality 0, compiling.
[0035.68] Warning: Warning, Failed to compile Material RX_Nature.Materials.M_Grass_Tweak_02a for platform PC-D3D-SM3, Default Material will be used in game.
[0035.72] Log: Missing cached shader map for material M_Flower_02, quality 0, compiling.
[0035.72] Warning: Warning, Failed to compile Material RX_Nature.Materials.M_Flower_02 for platform PC-D3D-SM3, Default Material will be used in game.
[0036.12] Log: Game class is 'Rx_Game'
[0036.12] Init: WinSock: Socket queue 131072 / 131072
[0037.20] Log: NetMode is now 1
[0037.24] Log: Primary PhysX scene will be in software.
[0037.24] Log: Creating Primary PhysX Scene.
[0037.43] Log: FKAggregateGeom::InstanceNovodexGeom: (Actor: CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.FogVolumeSphericalDensityInfo_2 Component: StaticMeshComponent_328 StaticMesh: EngineMeshes.Sphere) Cannot 3D-Scale rigid-body primitives (sphere, box, sphyl).
[0037.43] Log: URB_BodyInstance::InitBody : Could not create new Shape: Actor: CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.FogVolumeSphericalDensityInfo_2 Component: StaticMeshComponent_328 StaticMesh: EngineMeshes.Sphere
[0037.43] Log: Bringing World CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld up for play (30) at 2017.07.18-02.28.39
[0037.46] ScriptWarning: Accessed array 'Rx_MapListManager_0.AvailableGameProfiles' out of bounds (0/0)
        Rx_MapListManager CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_MapListManager_0
        Function RenX_Game.Rx_MapListManager:GetCurrentGameProfileIndex:00D3
[0037.46] ScriptLog: INITIAL:  -1 -1
[0037.47] ScriptLog: Game profile Index was NONE
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 248: Actor::setAngularDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] DevPhysics: Error (1) in file ..\..\Physics\src\NpActor.cpp, line 227: Actor::setLinearDamping: Actor must be dynamic!
[0037.48] Log: MIC::SetTextureParameterValue : Modifying 'MI_VH_GDI_Adaptive' during gameplay. ParamName: Camo
[0037.48] Log: MIC::SetTextureParameterValue : Modifying 'MI_VH_Nod_Adaptive' during gameplay. ParamName: Camo
[0037.48] Log: MIC::SetTextureParameterValue : Modifying 'MI_Cloak_Enemy_Adaptive' during gameplay. ParamName: Camo
[0037.48] Log: MIC::SetVectorParameterValue : Modifying 'MI_VH_GDI_Adaptive' during gameplay. ParamName: Camo_Colour
[0037.48] Log: MIC::SetVectorParameterValue : Modifying 'MI_VH_Nod_Adaptive' during gameplay. ParamName: Camo_Colour
[0037.48] Log: MIC::SetVectorParameterValue : Modifying 'MI_Cloak_Enemy_Adaptive' during gameplay. ParamName: Camo_Colour
[0037.49] ScriptLog: GDI:0.0000
[0037.49] ScriptLog: Nod:0.0000
[0037.54] ScriptWarning: Accessed array 'ProviderList' out of bounds (27/27)
        Rx_Game CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Game_0
        Function RenX_Game.Rx_Game:SetupMapDataList:0074
[0037.54] ScriptWarning: Accessed array 'ProviderList' out of bounds (27/27)
        Rx_Game CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Game_0
        Function RenX_Game.Rx_Game:SetupMapDataList:00AF
[0037.54] ScriptWarning: Accessed None 'ProviderList'
        Rx_Game CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Game_0
        Function RenX_Game.Rx_Game:SetupMapDataList:00AF
[0037.54] ScriptLog: NONE - ProviderList?
[0037.54] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Xmountain ---------YOSH----------
[0037.54] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Whiteout ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Walls_Flying ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-WallsNF ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Volcano ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Valley ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Under ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Tunnels ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-TrainingYard ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-TombRedux ---------YOSH----------
[0037.55] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Snow ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Reservoir ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Mesa ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-LakeSideNF ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-LakeSide ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Islands_Flying ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Islands ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-GoldRush ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Gobi ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Glasses ---------YOSH----------
[0037.56] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Fort ---------YOSH----------
[0037.57] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Field ---------YOSH----------
[0037.57] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Eyes ---------YOSH----------
[0037.57] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Crash_Site ---------YOSH----------
[0037.57] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Complex ---------YOSH----------
[0037.57] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Canyon ---------YOSH----------
[0037.57] ScriptLog: ------YOSH---------- CNC-Arctic_Stronghold ---------YOSH----------
[0037.59] Log: WARNING: Cooking Convex For Actor: CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_BuildingAttachment_PT_Nod_0 Component: StaticMeshComponent_67 StaticMesh: rx_deco_terminal.Mesh.SM_BU_PT (Scale: 1.000000 1.000000 1.000000) Please go and set PreCachedPhysScale on the mesh to have this scale for RunTime spawned objects.
[0037.59] Log: WARNING: Cooking Convex For Actor: CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_BuildingAttachment_MCT_0 Component: StaticMeshComponent_71 StaticMesh: rx_deco_terminal.Mesh.SM_BU_MCT (Scale: 1.000000 1.000000 1.000000) Please go and set PreCachedPhysScale on the mesh to have this scale for RunTime spawned objects.
[0037.59] Buildings: CRITICAL ERROR: Could not spawn  Rx_BuildingAttachment_Glass_AirTower At 1271.17,-10291.20,-4705.41 With a Rotation of 0,20416,0
[0037.59] Buildings: CRITICAL ERROR: Could not spawn  Rx_BuildingAttachment_Glass_AirTower At 1125.35,-10478.83,-4705.41 With a Rotation of 0,31339,0
[0037.59] Buildings: CRITICAL ERROR: Could not spawn  Rx_BuildingAttachment_Glass_AirTower At 1506.57,-10323.66,-4705.41 With a Rotation of 0,9493,0
[0037.60] Buildings: CRITICAL ERROR: Could not spawn  Rx_BuildingAttachment_Glass_AirTower At 1596.16,-10543.76,-4705.41 With a Rotation of 0,-1429,0
[0037.60] Buildings: CRITICAL ERROR: Could not spawn  Rx_BuildingAttachment_Glass_AirTower At 1450.34,-10731.39,-4705.41 With a Rotation of 0,-12352,0
[0037.60] Buildings: CRITICAL ERROR: Could not spawn  Rx_BuildingAttachment_Glass_AirTower At 1214.94,-10698.93,-4705.41 With a Rotation of 0,-23275,0
[0037.60] Log: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!   CPU skinned CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Building_Barracks_Internals_0.SkeletalMeshComponent_12 RX_BU_Barracks.Mesh.SK_BU_GDI_BAR 1 0 1 0
[0037.61] Log: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!   CPU skinned CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Building_Silo_Internals_0.SkeletalMeshComponent_29 RX_BU_Silo.Meshes.SK_BU_Silo 1 0 1 0
[0037.61] ScriptLog: BUILDING ERROR: No Trace2d_X sockets exist in Rx_Building_Silo_Internals_0
[0037.61] Log: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!   CPU skinned CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Building_Silo_Internals_1.SkeletalMeshComponent_30 RX_BU_Silo.Meshes.SK_BU_Silo 1 0 1 0
[0037.61] ScriptLog: BUILDING ERROR: No Trace2d_X sockets exist in Rx_Building_Silo_Internals_1
[0037.62] ScriptLog: Initializing Rx_GameEngine. Game Version: Open Beta 5.29
[0037.63] Rx: MAPLoaded;CNC-LakeSide
[0037.63] Log: Bringing up level for play took: 0.426769
[0037.63] Log: ########### Finished loading level: 11.247005 seconds
[0037.63] Init: Game engine initialized
[0037.64] Log: Initializing Game Engine Completed
[0037.70] ScriptLog: RCON: Attempting to connect to DevBot...
[0037.80] Log: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!   CPU skinned CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Building_Silo_Internals_0.SkeletalMeshComponent_29 RX_BU_Silo.Meshes.SK_BU_Silo 1 0 1 0
[0037.80] Log: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!   CPU skinned CNC-LakeSide.TheWorld:PersistentLevel.Rx_Building_Silo_Internals_1.SkeletalMeshComponent_30 RX_BU_Silo.Meshes.SK_BU_Silo 1 0 1 0
[0037.80] ScriptLog: RCON: Outgoing connection established.
[0037.80] Rx: RCONConnected;DevBot
[0037.81] Rx: RCONAuthenticated;DevBot
[0037.81] ScriptLog: (Actor): PlayParticleEffect on dedicated server!
[0037.81] ScriptLog: (Actor): PlayParticleEffect on dedicated server!
[0037.81] ScriptLog: (Actor): PlayParticleEffect on dedicated server!
[0037.81] ScriptLog: (Actor): PlayParticleEffect on dedicated server!
[0037.81] ScriptLog: (Actor): PlayParticleEffect on dedicated server!
[0037.81] ScriptLog: (Actor): PlayParticleEffect on dedicated server!
[0037.98] Warning: Warning, Failed to load 'Transient': Can't find file 'Transient'

 

thanks in advance

Edited July 18, 2017 by randomdude

[iTweek]

Hello. 

Turn off you Firewall or open the ports. Then it should go

[iTweek.]

worng account -.-

[randomdude]

ok now i get this log

 

[0132.63] NetComeGo: Open TheWorld 07/18/17 21:53:25 (friendsip)
[0166.14] NetComeGo: Close TcpNetDriver_0 TcpipConnection_0 (friendsip):51020 07/18/17 21:53:58
[0417.88] Rx: RCONConnected;Conn1
[0417.89] Rx: RCONDisconnected;Conn1

i had my windows firewall turned off but still no luck =-|

i can see ping behind my server when its hosted but my friend cant see ping =-\

 

[Sn4ke]

dont disable the firewall, just set exceptions for UDK for incoming and outgoing requests...

[randomdude]

yeah i also tried that but no luck either thats why i decide to turn off my windows firewall without luck, maby it has something to do with my modem firewall?

it got an option enabled
Strict Security Firewall
Block routing packet from WAN
maby i have to deselect that one? or is something else causing this issue?

 

[Fffreak9999]

Windows Firewall should have an inbound exception created for the UDK application.

Port forwarding should also point to the machine you are hosting the server on.

You can open a port, but on most router models just opening it does little, it needs to know where to send the data.

 

if the above criteria is met, it should work.

Are you able to connect to your own server?

[randomdude]

yeah i can join my own server and people who are connected to the internet in my home can join but my friend cant join from his housein my router i got the port 7777 forwarderd to my ip and in my modem i got the port 7777 forwarderd to my routers ip then it says the port is open

if select Respond ICMP Echo (ping) Request from WAN i can see an ip behind my server and i can join

but my friend is still unable to join he said he see a loading screen but after that it gets back to the main menu (the part where i see disconnected in my server log)

if my game is in the serverlist my friend doesnt see ping behind it

[Ukill]

This all sounds like a forward/firewall issue within your router, make sure the NAT function of your router is enabled, disable Bandwidth Control Services (Qos), and when you forward ports do both TCP and UDP.

What happens if you connect from your internal network to your WAN IP ?   

For testing purpose configure you router to a DMZ, this will forward all incoming requests to your server, there you disable your firewall and relative software for some minutes. 

Not sure about the following, but i think it is like : If he don't see any ping then you are nearby him (low ping) or you don't accept ICMP.

If you keep struggling, you can ask me for help in the Discord channel of Constructive Tyranny : https://discord.gg/5jHf5Z